Discussion:
[linux-audio-user] ANN: bristol 0.9.5-60
Nick Copeland
2006-09-18 20:03:49 UTC
Permalink
Bristol has been updated with a user configurable ARP 2600 synth. It has the
usual pre-patching as the original and, additionally, outputs can be
redirected to arbitrary inputs. This was a few changes to bristol to adjust
the engine buffer management for data that may feed back on itself, and
additionally a few extra operators for electroswitches, reverb and ring-mod,
etc. The envelope follower has not been tested at all and not all the patch
possibilities either as there are honestly too many to go through - about
600 possibilities with just a single cable.

The biggest changes were in the GUI. To support the user patches an extra
layer was added for their representation, then this was converted into a
transparency layer so the cables can be layered over the GUI to allow
control of the parameters without them 'getting in the way', then the cables
were coloured perhaps somewhat randomly - yellow patches carry signal left
to right, red cables carry signal right to left when see from the user
interface.
Once that was done I put in a cheesy watermarked logo - you can clear it
with the 'l' key or use the '-logo' option on the command line, but the
effect was too good to miss out on. The transparency can be toggled with the
't' key to allow you to foreground and background the layer, and 'o'/'O'
will adjust the depth of opacity. Load memory number 17, and play with the
'o' and 't' keys to get a feel for how the interface works. To patch, select
an output (the jack sockets light up for outputs) and then select an input
(these are just 'momentary'). This will direct the new engine routing
algorithm for each voice and then paint in the GUI. To clear a patch just
select either jack socket at the cable ends.


The net output of the synth is reminiscent of the sounds from the BBC
Radiophonic Workshop's greatest ever hit - the theme tune to 'Dr Who'. If
you don't know what that is don't worry, it's perhaps a bit obscure. The
original was composed on the elder brother of this synth - the ARP 2500 of
which the BBC had a few, so the results came as a pleasant surprise.

Graphics can be seen on the sourceforge homepage. Downloads as well of
course.

https://sourceforge.net/project/screenshots.php?group_id=157415

Regards,

Nick.

_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today it's FREE!
http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/
Tracey Hytry
2006-09-19 07:20:47 UTC
Permalink
-downloaded 0.9.5-60
-read the directions
-built it on FC5
-tested a few of the synth models using jack and an external midi keyboard
-so far, so good
-need to spend some time testing your newest models
-thanks

Tracey
Ernie Dulanowsky
2006-09-19 18:50:37 UTC
Permalink
Hi:

I had big fun with Bristol last night in my FC3/CCRMA machine. The ARP
2600 is fantastic, as are the Korgs.

Are there plans for other synth emulations ? I think you should do a
Synthi AKS, now
that you have some sort of patching capabilities....

cheers,
ernst
Post by Tracey Hytry
-downloaded 0.9.5-60
-read the directions
-built it on FC5
-tested a few of the synth models using jack and an external midi keyboard
-so far, so good
-need to spend some time testing your newest models
-thanks
Tracey
--
"Both Rob and I see sound as shapes.
I only have to do this (makes a fist)
and he knows what sound I mean". - Autechre
:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
Ernie Dulanowsky CCNA CWLSS
www.pulsewidth.ca
Post by Tracey Hytry
test_tones on www.cjtr.ca <<
Steven Walker
2006-09-20 02:08:26 UTC
Permalink
On Mon, 2006-09-18 at 16:27 -0400,
ANN: bristol 0.9.5-60
This looks interesting. It built OK, but when I run it, the GUI image
never appears - just an empty window.

Here are the messages:
# ./startBristol -b3
spawning midi thread
parent going into idle loop
connected to :0.0 (81442f0)
display is 1024 by 768 pixels
Window is w 1024, h 768, d 24, 0 0 0
Using DirectColor display
masks are ff0000 ff0000 ff0000
midi sequencer
Opened listening control socket: 5028
Client ID = 128
Queue ID = 0
Device name did not parse, defaults 128.0
Initialise the hammondB3 link to bristol: 814a7a8
hostname is localhost, bristol
port is 5028
Connected to the bristol control socket: 5
bristolengine already active
Accepted connection from 0 (3) onto 2 (5)
created 16 voices: allocated 16 to synth
engine MIDI channel 0
spawning audio thread
bristolAudioOpen(plughw:0,0, 44100, 256, 1200008)
audioOpen(b7f9a200, 0, 1024): plughw:0,0
opening device plughw:0,0, flags 0000000d
open playback on plughw:0,0, pre 8
Could not configure playback period size
period size is -1208655184
Problem opening audio device plughw:0,0, exiting audio thread
Rescheduled thread: 95
initialising one hammond sound
Null palette
Terminate MIDI signalling
Sylvain Robitaille
2006-09-20 04:24:02 UTC
Permalink
Post by Steven Walker
This looks interesting. It built OK, but when I run it, the GUI image
never appears - just an empty window.
I had the same problem to start with, until I figured out that it was
halting due to an inability to open the sound device that it was trying
Post by Steven Walker
...
spawning audio thread
bristolAudioOpen(plughw:0,0, 44100, 256, 1200008)
audioOpen(b7f9a200, 0, 1024): plughw:0,0
opening device plughw:0,0, flags 0000000d
open playback on plughw:0,0, pre 8
Could not configure playback period size
period size is -1208655184
Problem opening audio device plughw:0,0, exiting audio thread
...
On my system, audio "device" 0 is a virtual MIDI device (for some reason
which escapes me at the moment). I have audio output devices (soundcards,
the first built-in, and the second an add-on card) at "1,0" and "2,0".
For some reason I'm not able to get Bristol to use the add-on card at
2,0, though other audio applications (some through JACK, others not)
are able to.

Bristol is working for me if I add "-audiodev plughw:1,0", though its
output isn't very loud (compared to other audio applications), which I
worry about because I would ideally like to use it in lieu of hardware
synthesizers, and I'm as yet unable to get any MIDI control of it. :-(

I hope I've helped ... Can anyone help me control Bristol via MIDI?
--
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Sylvain Robitaille ***@alcor.concordia.ca

Major in Electroacoustic Studies Concordia University
Faculty of Fine Arts / Music Department Montreal, Quebec, Canada
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Jouni Rinne
2006-09-20 08:41:44 UTC
Permalink
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
Bristol is working for me if I add "-audiodev plughw:1,0", though its
output isn't very loud (compared to other audio applications)
Why is Bristol's output so quiet? At first I thought it wasn't producing any
sound at all, but then I began to hear faint sounds when hammering the keyboard,
and found out that I had to turn my amplifier up quite a bit before the sound
was on level with the other audio applications.

Is there something I could do to get more noise from Bristol? I'm using -jack as
an output.

JR
--
| ***@home ~$whoami ^ ^ | "Trust me, I know what I'm doing!" |
| Jouni 'Mad Max' Rinne ('x') | - Sledge Hammer |
| ***@home ~$man woman C " " | -------[ph34r t3h p3Ngu1n]-------- |
| Segmentation fault (core dumped) | l33tmmx at sci dot fi |
Paul Coccoli
2006-09-20 12:16:22 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jouni Rinne
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
Bristol is working for me if I add "-audiodev plughw:1,0", though its
output isn't very loud (compared to other audio applications)
Why is Bristol's output so quiet? At first I thought it wasn't producing any
sound at all, but then I began to hear faint sounds when hammering the keyboard,
and found out that I had to turn my amplifier up quite a bit before the sound
was on level with the other audio applications.
Is there something I could do to get more noise from Bristol? I'm using -jack as
an output.
JR
--
| Jouni 'Mad Max' Rinne ('x') | - Sledge Hammer |
| Segmentation fault (core dumped) | l33tmmx at sci dot fi |
Bristol has always been that quiet. For years. I don't know why the
developer doesn't fix it. Now htat it has jack support, that's easy
enough to remedy.

Can anyone familiar with the synths it emulates comment on their
quality (besides lack of volume)?

Now who's got a LASH patch for this?
Malte Steiner
2006-09-25 12:15:04 UTC
Permalink
Hi,

got bristol compiled and running with jack on ubuntu laptop. Had some
fun with the new ARP 2600 although the gui is a but sluggish while
changing patches from the memorys.

I wounder if there supposed to be an installation routine like

./build install

or something. Couldn't find one and ended up copying the required libs
to the right places manually.

Cheers,

Malte
--
Malte Steiner
media art + development
-www.block4.com-

next events:
elektronengehirn exhibition, lecture + concert @ Piksel 2006, Bergen,
Norway 12.-15. october

more at blog 4, also available as rss feed:
http://java.block4.com/blog4/
Nick Copeland
2006-09-20 20:31:39 UTC
Permalink
Nice piece of work on the issue with the audio device access failing.

This does indeed happen - if the GUI does not get a response from the engine
(that is started before it) then it kind of hangs. I will work on this. It
had been reported before, but I rested on the case that 'it works on my
system' so I could not reproduce it. Next release hopefully I can get it to
exit gracefully if the audio device is not available, or that it responds
correctly to other device specifications.

Yes, the gain is low, but I did not know it was THAT low. Can you try using
the 'startBristol -gain 8', or more than 8 if you need, to increase the
final stage output gain. Watch out for the B3 though, it still thumps out at
quite a high level by comparison. I will mention that a fix other than the
final output stage gain is a bit gruesome, since the internals rely on the
signal levels used by the application - changing those would affect
filtering levels, for example, and especially when the emphasis is high. If
you are working with 16bit audio then using the output gain should not
really reduce the quality, but at 24bits, if you have this resoution, then
it is a non optimal solution for various reasons. Another alterntive is too
buy a couple of mallets with which to whallop your master keyboard. No? Ok,
I would not have gone for that one either.

Regarding MIDI support - what do need bristol to do? It should respond to a
MIDI keyboard to allow you to play notes, but a the moment it will not link
its controls to MIDI Continuous Controllers. That is also due to be changed
as part of some usability enhancements: it should include controller
mappings from the GUI, save the settings to a per synth memory (not per
memory, just one setting per synth), it should support program change
messages and allow the keyboard graphic to reflect the state of the midi
keyboard (I am personally against this - tying two synths together allows
one to play the other, but it does not cause the keys on one to be depressed
via midi. Either way, people like it so it will probably be implemented).

Is this what you need? It something have put on the to-do list.

On a related issue, what are other wishes for bristol? My plans are the midi
support, lash support, a korg ms-20 type synth, finalise the mixer and
perhaps add a bristol modular although I don't like this last idea to much
as it goes against the idea of being an emulator.

I will put the EMS Synthi on the list, although I don't have a breadboard
patching and I was not aware they had patch cable controlled synths - this
is EMS, no? I will admit to wanting to work on some of their synths already,
but if I get a breadboard then perhaps an ARP 2500 is on the cards although
that is a lot more work.

Kind Regards, and many thanks for the feedback. A wishlist would make me
happy, above and beyond what is in this mail.

Nick.
Reply-To: A list for linux audio users
Subject: Re: [linux-audio-user] Re: ANN: bristol 0.9.5-60
Date: Wed, 20 Sep 2006 08:16:22 -0400
Post by Jouni Rinne
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
Bristol is working for me if I add "-audiodev plughw:1,0", though its
output isn't very loud (compared to other audio applications)
Why is Bristol's output so quiet? At first I thought it wasn't producing
any
sound at all, but then I began to hear faint sounds when hammering the
keyboard,
and found out that I had to turn my amplifier up quite a bit before the
sound
was on level with the other audio applications.
Is there something I could do to get more noise from Bristol? I'm using
-jack as
an output.
JR
--
| Jouni 'Mad Max' Rinne ('x') | - Sledge Hammer |
| Segmentation fault (core dumped) | l33tmmx at sci dot fi |
Bristol has always been that quiet. For years. I don't know why the
developer doesn't fix it. Now htat it has jack support, that's easy
enough to remedy.
Can anyone familiar with the synths it emulates comment on their
quality (besides lack of volume)?
Now who's got a LASH patch for this?
_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today it's FREE!
http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/
Tim Howard
2006-09-20 23:53:06 UTC
Permalink
Post by Nick Copeland
On a related issue, what are other wishes for bristol? My plans are the midi
support, lash support, a korg ms-20 type synth, finalise the mixer and
perhaps add a bristol modular although I don't like this last idea to much
as it goes against the idea of being an emulator.
I really love the sounds of this synth, but one thing that is a little
aggravating (and I've noticed this on other synth GUIs as well) is
that it is so hard to adjust the knobs in a "fine-tuning" way. It
would be really slick if you could, for example, right click on a knob
and have it change into fine-tuning mode. Just a thought. :-)

-TimH
Sylvain Robitaille
2006-09-21 02:38:06 UTC
Permalink
Post by Nick Copeland
Nice piece of work on the issue with the audio device access failing.
Thanks. I'm still not sure why I'm unable to use "-audiodev plughw:2,0"
on my system, as that's the add-in card I normally use with other sound
applications, rather than the built-in interface at "plughw:1,0", which
seems to work without any difficulty with Bristol. I tried "-jack"
(JACK running on interface 2,0), but every time I tried to play a note
Bristol silently exited.

Nevertheless, I can work around this by using the built-in interface
for Bristol (I'll need to run a separate set of cables to my hardware
mixer to get this output without repatching the audio out, but that's
not a serious issue at all), and the add-on card for other apps.
Post by Nick Copeland
Can you try using the 'startBristol -gain 8', or more than 8 if you
need, to increase the final stage output gain.
Ah, yes; that does it. Thank you. I can setup command aliases to start
different synths at various gain levels, as necessary. So far it seems
that "-gain 64" is quite reasonable on my system, though that _feels_
like it should be scary high. I haven't checked the B3 yet, but like
I said, I can make a point of setting it differently if necessary.
Post by Nick Copeland
If you are working with 16bit audio then using the output gain should
not really reduce the quality, ...
It sounds just fine to me (in 16-bit) on my system, but I haven't
tested extensively; (I don't really like playing a synth with a mouse,
I'm afraid).
Post by Nick Copeland
Another alterntive is too buy a couple
of mallets with which to whallop your master keyboard. No?
Ummmm .... no. :-) A MIDI-marimba, perhaps?
Post by Nick Copeland
Regarding MIDI support - what do need bristol to do?
Well, I would like to be able to control it via MIDI from an external
keyboard (nothing particularly fancy), but so far haven't been able to
do that. I'm quite certain that I'm just not giving the correct options.
Post by Nick Copeland
It should respond to a MIDI keyboard to allow you to play notes,
Right. No luck yet. I would certainly appreciate ideas of where I
should be looking.
Post by Nick Copeland
but a the moment it will not link its controls to MIDI Continuous
Controllers.
I'm not very picky: I'd like to be able to play the keyboard and
have Bristol produce the sound, though it would be nice to be able to
manipulate "standard" controllers (pitch and mod wheels, damper pedal,
volume control, assuming controller properly sends the messages) and have
them perform the expected action. Being able to manipulate knobs via
MIDI CC, in my opinion would be nice, but it would be icing on the cake.

Ultimately, I'll likely want to control Bristol also from a guitar-to-MIDI
converter, which tends to send a lot of pitch-bend information, so at
least that much would matter to me ...
Post by Nick Copeland
it should support program change messages ...
Yes, though I don't mind clicking the mouse for that. My own needs are
generally simple (I'm really a guitar player, not a keyboard player).
Post by Nick Copeland
allow the keyboard graphic to reflect the state of the midi keyboard
Shrug ... I imagine that this may affect performance of the program.
If it does, I'd prefer to be able to disable it, and redirect the
performance to sound-generation instead ... My opinion is that if I
can get MIDI keyboard control to work at all, the on-screen keyboard is
useful only for testing output, and perhaps to listen to changes while
progamming sounds.

Maybe a blinking "LED" to acknowledge receipt of MIDI data, though?
I miss that on hardware synths, but use a physical LED to troubleshoot
MIDI routing when I need to.
Post by Nick Copeland
tying two synths together allows one to play the other, but it does
not cause the keys on one to be depressed via midi.
Agreed.
Post by Nick Copeland
On a related issue, what are other wishes for bristol?
Now that you have virtual cables implemented, an MS20 would be really
nice ... :-)

In my case, though, an MS20 implies being able to patch in external audio.
Perhaps you already handled that with the 2600 emulation, though?
(I don't know if the physical 2600 allowed for external audio to be
patched in, but I imagine it must have) Would it be something you would
consider adding to Bristol?
Post by Nick Copeland
My plans are the midi support, lash support, a korg ms-20 type synth, ...
bingo! :-)
Post by Nick Copeland
finalise the mixer ...
Am I understanding correctly that the mixer is intended to be usable
to mix and process multiple instances of Bristol synth emulations into
a single output? Maybe the mixer and synth emulations could all work
through Jack, so the mixer could be used to mix other signals as well?
Am I asking for too much?
Post by Nick Copeland
perhaps add a bristol modular although I don't like this last idea to
much as it goes against the idea of being an emulator.
Emulate the modules of some of the original modulars? I'm not trying
to convince you, as I imagine that you already have thought of that ...
Post by Nick Copeland
I will put the EMS Synthi on the list, although I don't have a breadboard
patching and I was not aware they had patch cable controlled synths -
this is EMS, no?
Yes.
tim hall
2006-09-23 07:59:56 UTC
Permalink
Post by Nick Copeland
I will put the EMS Synthi on the list, although I don't have a breadboard
patching and I was not aware they had patch cable controlled synths -
this is EMS, no?
Yes.  
Sylvain Robitaille
2006-10-01 06:17:28 UTC
Permalink
I just wanted to followup on a previous message, since I had reported
inability to get Bristol to respond to MIDI events, or to cooperate with
JACK on my system ...
I tried "-jack" (JACK running on interface 2,0), but every time I
tried to play a note Bristol silently exited.
Figured this out first: I had JACK set to 44.1KHz, for a project I'm
working on. Changed it to 48KHz, and it's fine. I'll have to see
if there's some way to programmatically _check_ the sample rate that
JACK is set to, and use that in a script to start Bristol with (using
appropriate sample-rate options), I think, so that I'll be able to give
myself a simple menu of Bristol emulations to choose from. :-)

If I can make it suitably elegant, I'll submit that as a patch to the
startBristol script, but I'll know more whether what I do is worth
considering for than once I've done it. Worst case, at least on my
system where I use Qjackctl, it looks like I can just look for jackd in
a process listing and use its "-r" argument to determine the sample
rate.
Post by Nick Copeland
It should respond to a MIDI keyboard to allow you to play notes,
Right. No luck yet. I would certainly appreciate ideas of where I
should be looking.
Figured this out as well: I needed to manually add a MIDI input
connector to JACK for Bristol, and "connect" the hardware MIDI device to
it, then _activate_ that new setup. Now I'm able to use Bristol with my
MIDI keyboards (haven't tried yet with the guitar-to-MIDI converter, but
I expect that will work as well, though the converter generates a lot of
pitch-bend information.
Post by Nick Copeland
but a the moment it will not link its controls to MIDI Continuous
Controllers.
Right. No response to pitch-bend or mod-wheels, it seems. Those are
the two I consider most important, though I realize that once you solve
the general case, these will easily fall into place. My MIDI keyboards
are (classic?) synths in their own rights (an ESQ1 and a DW8000), so I'm
not looking to assign banks of 8 knobs and sliders to various
parameters, but the ability to use the pitch-bend and mod controls on
Bristol from the keyboards would be fantastic. Also, program-change
commands, if that isn't already inplemented (I haven't actually tried, I
admit).
I'm not very picky: I'd like to be able to play the keyboard and
have Bristol produce the sound, ...
I'm very happy to report this now works for me! :-) :-) :-)

Thank you VERY much, for all the work you do on this, Nick!
--
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Sylvain Robitaille ***@alcor.concordia.ca

Major in Electroacoustic Studies Concordia University
Faculty of Fine Arts / Music Department Montreal, Quebec, Canada
----------------------------------------------------------------------
tim hall
2006-09-23 07:30:47 UTC
Permalink
Post by Nick Copeland
On a related issue, what are other wishes for bristol? My plans are the
midi support, lash support, a korg ms-20 type synth, finalise the mixer and
perhaps add a bristol modular although I don't like this last idea to much
as it goes against the idea of being an emulator.
I will put the EMS Synthi on the list, although I don't have a breadboard
patching and I was not aware they had patch cable controlled synths - this
is EMS, no? I will admit to wanting to work on some of their synths
already, but if I get a breadboard then perhaps an ARP 2500 is on the cards
although that is a lot more work.
I confess to not having looked at Bristol for a long time. Last time I looked
it didn't work at all on my system and I wasn't savvy enough to send in any
kind of bug report. I *need* a decent analog synth emulator. If you really
have plans to incorporate MS-20 and EMS Synthi type synths, I will gladly
help test them out. I don't understand what you mean by breadboard - this is
some sort of patching system? If you can even figure out how to digitally
simulate EMS filters, it would constitute a Major victory in my books.

Anyhow, it's clearly time to have a serious play around with Bristol. Good to
know you're on the case. :)
--
cheers,

tim hall
http://glastonburymusic.org.uk/tim
We are the people We've been waiting for.
Yves Potin
2006-09-23 08:28:25 UTC
Permalink
Post by tim hall
I confess to not having looked at Bristol for a long time. Last time I looked
it didn't work at all on my system and I wasn't savvy enough to send in any
kind of bug report. I *need* a decent analog synth emulator.
You should try the last version, it's really awesome. Jack support
works perfectly, I'm now working on the official doc of the ARP 2600 to
re-learn and re-think the basis of synthesis and learn how such a wonder
could work. ( http://guitarfool.com/ARP2600.html ).
Nick, great thanks for your work :).
Cheers,

Y.
Nick Copeland
2006-09-21 08:59:15 UTC
Permalink
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
I'm still not sure why I'm unable to use "-audiodev plughw:2,0"
At the moment all of my development is done on a laptop, my tower system is
in storage in the UK so I don't have access to multiple soundcards to really
test this one.
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
but every time I tried to play a note [with jack] Bristol silently exited.
The engine has probably exit due to not being able to open the audio
interface, or has core dumped. If you have coredumpsize enabled we would
debug that case. The only reasons I know of for failing to open jack is
permissions if you do not have the PAM modules enabled then bristol may not
have the desired rights to connect?
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
I can setup command aliases to start different synths at various gain
levels
Ah, at the moment you can't, the final stage output gain is in the audio
engine, not in the emulation, so it applies to all synths. I can change this
reasonably quickly though, next upload should be able to do this by synth
since the feature looks like being useful.
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
Well, I would like to be able to control it via MIDI from an external
keyboard
This does work, in as much as it was architected to support this and other
people report that it works. I will be testing with a USB keyboard this
weekend so may get you an update.
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
manipulate "standard" controllers (pitch and mod wheels, damper pedal,
[etc])
Here is the lowdown on MIDI in bristol. The GUI and the engine are separate
processes. They speak SYSEX messages to adjust the parameters, and the
keyboard sends NOTE events - all across a TCP socket primarily from GUI to
engine (there are some acknowledgements). Separately the engine listens, per
default, to the ALSA SEQ or raw MIDI interface for MIDI events. It only
supports the following: NOTE ON/OFF, CONTINUOUS 0 and 1 for pitch and mod
wheels, and the memory moog should respond to controllers 7 and 11 for two
foot pedals - expression and volume.

I was not sure whether to implement the sustain pedal. Most master keyboards
will use this to control sending note off events for sustain, so bristol
then does not have too.

Now when it comes to controlling parameters, this is a GUI function. The GUI
will have to register to receive MIDI events as well as the engine, change
its potentiometer settings and then tell the engine to adjust its
operational parameters. Also for program change events it is the GUI that
has memories, not the engine. In my opinion this is the correct approach,
but it introduces a couple of issues regarding controller manipulation.
Either way controls will be implemented and I will maintain an option for
tracking the keyboard in the GUI for the reasons you state.

The engine will eventually conform a bit closer to the GM2 specification,
which means it will allow you to control filter and envelopes, etc, with
some default controller numbers as per that spec. No dates for this.

The keyboard graphic has been reported as being 'klunky' to use, and that
its model of click on/click off is arguably wrong. It was never intended to
actually play the synth using this keyboard, it was put in for a couple of
reasons - firstly it looked good, the GUI should be able to represent the
original instrument. Secondly it allows me to at least test and control it
without having to have my master keyboard attached (and seeing as that is
also in storage, just as well). On related note, the ARP 2600 has a button
next to the envelope controls that allow you to generate sounds without a
keyboard - this is the same as the original unit and again allows testing a
synth that does not in this case even have the keyboard graphic.
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
Maybe a blinking "LED" to acknowledge receipt of MIDI data, though?
For future study. There are issues here regarding the fact that the engine
and GUI are separate processes - the LED should reflect MIDI traffic in the
engine, but that would require the engine inform the GUI that events have
occured, itself an overhead and outside of the current communication model.
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
an MS20
The main issue I see here is that whilst bristol does take a copy of the
input data and present it to all the synths (the Mini/Explorer have external
inputs, the ARP also but not widely tested) to manipulate the sounds, the
MS-20 had this groovy Hz->Volts converter, allowing it to be used as a
vocorder. This is notoriously difficult to emulate digitally, but it is down
on my list. It is likely to first appears in something called a 2610 or so,
the ARP 2600 with additional voltage manipulators (inverters, lin/log, spare
mixers) as per the original instrument, but also with this frequency to
control signal extractor.
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
the mixer is intended to be usable to mix and process multiple instances of
Bristol?
The honest truth is that I have really specified what the mixer will be for.
It is intended to be a realtime mix for both audio and emulated streams, and
the intention is to use multichannel hardware and also to register multiple
IO with Jack to allow it to remix audio from different sources. The thing
is, Ardour already does this and a lot more exceptionally well, so with Jack
integrated into bristol kind of removes the requirement for a bristol mixer.
Having said that I like mixers and I like the bristol mixer interface, so it
will happen at some point. There are a lot of differences in the design of
these two mixing apps - I kind of like the sometimes rather kluterred
bristol mixer interface rather than a load of drop down menus and screens.
Personal choice.
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
the Synthi 100 was a massive unit
I was more thinking of the A series, the 100 graphics would not fit on any
reasonable monitor! That is not to say I would not consider something like
the Synthi 100, just not right yet. Put it this way, I wanted to have an ARP
2600 but knew that would be a lot of work, a big learning curve, so before
starting on the 2600 I implemented the Axxe and Odyssey. The Axxe gave me
the right operator set, the Odyssey added in the routing capabilities via
switches, and finally the 2600 tied them all together with the patching
interface. This was also done for the OBXa (did an OBX first) and for the
Prophets (did a 5 before a 10). The same would happen with the EMS synths as
well.
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
Moog Taurus?
Am not convinved - you would need to do a sales pitch on me. The other
synths can do the sounds, and I am not sure I want to work on the graphics
for a pedalboard.

Kind regards,

Nick.

_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today it's FREE!
http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/
David Baron
2006-09-21 12:42:32 UTC
Permalink
Yes, Nice piece of work.

However, I have the following problems on my Debian Sid box:

1. This new version seems to always load two instances of the requested synth:
One without and one with the watermark.

2. After closing one synth and invoking another, the sounds of the previous
one are still active. Cannot always get the new one to change.

3. Jack did not work.

4. Some of the synths get no sound. I may be I do not know how to use them.
B3, Rhodes, Mini work out of the box.

MIDI works fine but one must specify the -mididev if this is not the first
alsa/oss device. Mine being the second one, I have to give it /dev/midi1 in a
OSS mode and hw129:0 in ALSA. I assume there is a way of (setting up for)
using device names instead of this stuff.
Jean-Baptiste Mestelan
2006-09-26 07:40:59 UTC
Permalink
Post by David Baron
MIDI works fine but one must specify the -mididev if this is not the first
alsa/oss device. Mine being the second one, I have to give it /dev/midi1 in a
OSS mode and hw129:0 in ALSA. I assume there is a way of (setting up for)
using device names instead of this stuff.
Please, David :
how did you make out the correct id (hw129) for your midi device ?
I also have a USB keyboard as my second soundcard, but I cannot make
out its id ...
It is listed in /proc/devices as KONTROL49, but that is not a correct
id for Bristol, obviously ...

Also, to Nick :
would it be possible for Bristol MIDI connections to show up in
QJackctl or Patchage ? This would enable ignorants like me to patch
Bristol to their MIDI devices :-)

Regards.
David Baron
2006-09-21 14:49:18 UTC
Permalink
On Thursday 21 September 2006 16:37,
Post by Nick Copeland
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
but every time I tried to play a note [with jack] Bristol silently exited.
The engine has probably exit due to not being able to open the audio
interface, or has core dumped. If you have coredumpsize enabled we would
debug that case. The only reasons I know of for failing to open jack is
permissions if you do not have the PAM modules enabled then bristol may not
have the desired rights to connect?
I am running mine with a realtime-lsm enabled kernel. Any member of the
"audio" group should be able to use jack. Jack starts fine. Bristol cannot
interface it.

Do I need suid? If so, where and how do I set it (engine?)
Frieder Bürzele
2006-09-21 16:47:00 UTC
Permalink
I get this


cc -g -fPIC -D_BRISTOL_JACK -I../include -I. -I/usr/local/include
-I/usr/include/jack bristoljack.o bristolmixer.o bristolprophet52.o
bristolobx.o bristolpoly.o bristolvox.o vox.o sdco.o sdcoutils.o
bristolsampler.o vibrachorus.o thesermon.o bristolexplorer.o filter2.o
lfo.o bristoldx.o hpf.o junodco.o bristoljuno.o dimensionD.o expdco.o
bristolsystem.o bristolhammond.o bristolprophet.o prophetdco.o filter.o
noise.o hammond.o audioEngine.o resonator.o dxop.o midihandlers.o
bristolmm.o midinote.o envelope.o dca.o rotary.o bristolmain.o dco.o
midithread.o audiothread.o soundManager.o -o bristol -L/usr/lib
-L/usr/local/lib -L../../slab/libslabaudio -L../libbristol
-L../libbristolmidi -L../libbristol -L/usr/lib/jack -Xlinker -Bdynamic
-lc -lm -lpthread -lasound -lbristol -lbristolmidi -lslabaudio -ljack
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x4c): undefined reference to `arpdcoinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x50): undefined reference to `ringmodinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x54): undefined reference to `eswitchinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x58): undefined reference to `reverbinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x5c): undefined reference to `followerinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xcc): undefined reference to `bristolPoly6Init'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xd0): undefined reference to `bristolAxxeInit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xd4): undefined reference to `bristolOdysseyInit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xd8): undefined reference to
`bristolMemoryMoogInit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xdc): undefined reference to `bristolArp2600Init'
collect2: ld returned 1 exit status
make[1]: *** [bristol] Error 1
make[1]: Leaving directory
`/var/tmp/portage/bristol-0.9.5.60/work/bristol-0.9.5/src/bristol/bristol'
make: *** [all] Error 2


Greetz
Frieder
Frieder Bürzele
2006-09-21 17:34:54 UTC
Permalink
Post by Frieder Bürzele
I get this
cc -g -fPIC -D_BRISTOL_JACK -I../include -I. -I/usr/local/include
-I/usr/include/jack bristoljack.o bristolmixer.o bristolprophet52.o
bristolobx.o bristolpoly.o bristolvox.o vox.o sdco.o sdcoutils.o
bristolsampler.o vibrachorus.o thesermon.o bristolexplorer.o filter2.o
lfo.o bristoldx.o hpf.o junodco.o bristoljuno.o dimensionD.o expdco.o
bristolsystem.o bristolhammond.o bristolprophet.o prophetdco.o
filter.o noise.o hammond.o audioEngine.o resonator.o dxop.o
midihandlers.o bristolmm.o midinote.o envelope.o dca.o rotary.o
bristolmain.o dco.o midithread.o audiothread.o soundManager.o -o
bristol -L/usr/lib -L/usr/local/lib -L../../slab/libslabaudio
-L../libbristol -L../libbristolmidi -L../libbristol -L/usr/lib/jack
-Xlinker -Bdynamic -lc -lm -lpthread -lasound -lbristol -lbristolmidi
-lslabaudio -ljack
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x4c): undefined reference to `arpdcoinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x50): undefined reference to `ringmodinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x54): undefined reference to `eswitchinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x58): undefined reference to `reverbinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x5c): undefined reference to `followerinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xcc): undefined reference to `bristolPoly6Init'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xd0): undefined reference to `bristolAxxeInit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xd4): undefined reference to
`bristolOdysseyInit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xd8): undefined reference to
`bristolMemoryMoogInit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xdc): undefined reference to
`bristolArp2600Init'
collect2: ld returned 1 exit status
make[1]: *** [bristol] Error 1
make[1]: Leaving directory
`/var/tmp/portage/bristol-0.9.5.60/work/bristol-0.9.5/src/bristol/bristol'
make: *** [all] Error 2
Greetz
Frieder
sorry for the noise it was my fault
Nick Copeland
2006-09-24 13:42:51 UTC
Permalink
Was this from the 'build' script in the 'src' directory or from a make in
the engine directory? You can use the makefile directly, but the wrapper in
the src directory will build all the dependent libraries first. This is
still strange output though, the unresolved calls should be for sourcecode
resident in this directory.

Regards,

Nick.
Reply-To: A list for linux audio users
Subject: Re: [linux-audio-user] ANN: bristol 0.9.5-60
Date: Thu, 21 Sep 2006 19:34:54 +0200
Post by Frieder Bürzele
I get this
cc -g -fPIC -D_BRISTOL_JACK -I../include -I. -I/usr/local/include
-I/usr/include/jack bristoljack.o bristolmixer.o bristolprophet52.o
bristolobx.o bristolpoly.o bristolvox.o vox.o sdco.o sdcoutils.o
bristolsampler.o vibrachorus.o thesermon.o bristolexplorer.o filter2.o
lfo.o bristoldx.o hpf.o junodco.o bristoljuno.o dimensionD.o expdco.o
bristolsystem.o bristolhammond.o bristolprophet.o prophetdco.o filter.o
noise.o hammond.o audioEngine.o resonator.o dxop.o midihandlers.o
bristolmm.o midinote.o envelope.o dca.o rotary.o bristolmain.o dco.o
midithread.o audiothread.o soundManager.o -o bristol -L/usr/lib
-L/usr/local/lib -L../../slab/libslabaudio -L../libbristol
-L../libbristolmidi -L../libbristol -L/usr/lib/jack -Xlinker -Bdynamic -lc
-lm -lpthread -lasound -lbristol -lbristolmidi -lslabaudio -ljack
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x4c): undefined reference to `arpdcoinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x50): undefined reference to `ringmodinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x54): undefined reference to `eswitchinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x58): undefined reference to `reverbinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x5c): undefined reference to `followerinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xcc): undefined reference to `bristolPoly6Init'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xd0): undefined reference to `bristolAxxeInit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xd4): undefined reference to
`bristolOdysseyInit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xd8): undefined reference to
`bristolMemoryMoogInit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xdc): undefined reference to
`bristolArp2600Init'
collect2: ld returned 1 exit status
make[1]: *** [bristol] Error 1
make[1]: Leaving directory
`/var/tmp/portage/bristol-0.9.5.60/work/bristol-0.9.5/src/bristol/bristol'
make: *** [all] Error 2
Greetz
Frieder
sorry for the noise it was my fault
_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today it's FREE!
http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/
Frieder Bürzele
2006-09-26 00:07:17 UTC
Permalink
Post by Nick Copeland
Was this from the 'build' script in the 'src' directory or from a make
in the engine directory? You can use the makefile directly, but the
wrapper in the src directory will build all the dependent libraries
first. This is still strange output though, the unresolved calls
should be for sourcecode resident in this directory.
Regards,
Nick.
I bumped a gentoo ebuild to the new bristol version, but forgot to
delete the makefile patch
which was needed for the old bristol version

Frieder
Post by Nick Copeland
Reply-To: A list for linux audio users
Subject: Re: [linux-audio-user] ANN: bristol 0.9.5-60
Date: Thu, 21 Sep 2006 19:34:54 +0200
Post by Frieder Bürzele
I get this
cc -g -fPIC -D_BRISTOL_JACK -I../include -I. -I/usr/local/include
-I/usr/include/jack bristoljack.o bristolmixer.o bristolprophet52.o
bristolobx.o bristolpoly.o bristolvox.o vox.o sdco.o sdcoutils.o
bristolsampler.o vibrachorus.o thesermon.o bristolexplorer.o
filter2.o lfo.o bristoldx.o hpf.o junodco.o bristoljuno.o
dimensionD.o expdco.o bristolsystem.o bristolhammond.o
bristolprophet.o prophetdco.o filter.o noise.o hammond.o
audioEngine.o resonator.o dxop.o midihandlers.o bristolmm.o
midinote.o envelope.o dca.o rotary.o bristolmain.o dco.o
midithread.o audiothread.o soundManager.o -o bristol -L/usr/lib
-L/usr/local/lib -L../../slab/libslabaudio -L../libbristol
-L../libbristolmidi -L../libbristol -L/usr/lib/jack -Xlinker
-Bdynamic -lc -lm -lpthread -lasound -lbristol -lbristolmidi
-lslabaudio -ljack
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x4c): undefined reference to `arpdcoinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x50): undefined reference to `ringmodinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x54): undefined reference to `eswitchinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x58): undefined reference to `reverbinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0x5c): undefined reference to `followerinit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xcc): undefined reference to
`bristolPoly6Init'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xd0): undefined reference to
`bristolAxxeInit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xd4): undefined reference to
`bristolOdysseyInit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xd8): undefined reference to
`bristolMemoryMoogInit'
audiothread.o:(.data.rel+0xdc): undefined reference to
`bristolArp2600Init'
collect2: ld returned 1 exit status
make[1]: *** [bristol] Error 1
make[1]: Leaving directory
`/var/tmp/portage/bristol-0.9.5.60/work/bristol-0.9.5/src/bristol/bristol'
make: *** [all] Error 2
Greetz
Frieder
sorry for the noise it was my fault
_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today it's
FREE! http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/
Nick Copeland
2006-09-24 13:54:33 UTC
Permalink
Post by David Baron
1. This new version seems to always load two instances of the requested
Hm. I have never seen this. What is the output from 'which startBristol'?
Post by David Baron
2. After the sounds of the previous one are still active.
Multiitimbral. How did you close the synth window? If you do it with ^C, or
destroy the window then I do not always have a change to remove the synth
from the engine. It then lingers on the same midi channel. This was half
intentional, to allow for multitimbral support, but killing the GUI from the
window titlebar should result in a graceful remove of the emulation as well
as the GUI.
Post by David Baron
3. Jack did not work.
There are a few other complaints of this one, am looking into it.
Post by David Baron
4. Some of the synths get no sound.
Ah, that may have been me. Some of the default synth memories have volume
set to zero - I needed to use them to test the ARP 2600 which has no
keyboard. The up/down memory keys should load the first available one. I
will fix this in the next upload, it may also be an issue with a late
enhancement: the -load <memory index> will allow you to set the first memory
location. Default value is 'zero', but some of the synths do not have a
memory number zero since they take 'bank' numbers that start from '1'.
Post by David Baron
MIDI works fine but one must specify the -mididev if this is not the first
alsa/oss device. Mine being the second one, I have to give it /dev/midi1 in
a
OSS mode and hw129:0 in ALSA. I assume there is a way of (setting up for)
using device names instead of this stuff.
_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today it's FREE!
http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/
Malte Steiner
2006-09-24 23:36:04 UTC
Permalink
Hello,

thanks for the new version, have to check out.
Post by Nick Copeland
The net output of the synth is reminiscent of the sounds from the BBC
Radiophonic Workshop's greatest ever hit - the theme tune to 'Dr Who'.
If you don't know what that is don't worry, it's perhaps a bit obscure.
The original was composed on the elder brother of this synth - the ARP
2500 of which the BBC had a few, so the results came as a pleasant
surprise.
?

The theme was produced around 1963 before the ARP was available, it was
realized by the incredible Delia Derbyshire with the help of some
oscillators, filters and in the first place, tape splicing techniques.
Maybe later renditions are created with an ARP but more likly on a
Synthi 100 (the model at BBC was dubbed Delaware) which is actually a
modular synth.

Check out

http://www.delia-derbyshire.org/

EMS Synthis with patch cords are the Synthi Logic and Synthi E

http://www.emsrehberg.de/SYNTHI__s/synthi__s.html

but I guess most of the wirednes of the Synthis came from the
patchmatrix which might introduce lot of crosstalk.
When you simulate the MS20 filter I think you are rather close to the
EMS one. In a simular league the WASP might be too..

Cheers,

Malte
--
Malte Steiner
media art + development
-www.block4.com-

next events:
elektronengehirn exhibition, lecture + concert @ Piksel 2006, Bergen,
Norway 12.-15. october

more at blog 4, also available as rss feed:
http://java.block4.com/blog4/
David Baron
2006-09-25 10:47:57 UTC
Permalink
Post by Nick Copeland
Post by David Baron
1. This new version seems to always load two instances of the requested
Hm. I have never seen this. What is the output from 'which startBristol'?
I was doing startBristol locally ./startBristol. The previous version is
on /usr/local/bin.
Post by Nick Copeland
Post by David Baron
2. After the sounds of the previous one are still active.
Multiitimbral. How did you close the synth window? If you do it with ^C, or
destroy the window then  I do not always have a change to remove the synth
from the engine. It then lingers on the same midi channel. This was half
intentional, to allow for multitimbral support, but killing the GUI from
the window titlebar should result in a graceful remove of the emulation as
well as the GUI.
I will retry this. I believe I clicked the title-bar [x] to close them. GUI
disappeared, sounds did not.
Post by Nick Copeland
Post by David Baron
4. Some of the synths get no sound.
Ah, that may have been me. Some of the default synth memories have volume
set to zero - I needed to use them to test the ARP 2600 which has no
keyboard. The up/down memory keys should load the first available one. I
will fix this in the next upload, it may also be an issue with a late
enhancement: the -load <memory index> will allow you to set the first
memory location. Default value is 'zero', but some of the synths do not
have a memory number zero since they take 'bank' numbers that start from
'1'.
I noticed this as well. Maybe I just could not figure out how to work them. I
needed to set the volume on those that did work. Setting a patch go another
to work. Others, no success but that might be me. Never used the real ones.
tim hall
2006-09-28 10:28:13 UTC
Permalink
Post by David Baron
Post by Nick Copeland
Post by David Baron
2. After the sounds of the previous one are still active.
Multiitimbral. How did you close the synth window? If you do it with ^C,
or destroy the window then  I do not always have a change to remove the
synth from the engine. It then lingers on the same midi channel. This was
half intentional, to allow for multitimbral support, but killing the GUI
from the window titlebar should result in a graceful remove of the
emulation as well as the GUI.
I will retry this. I believe I clicked the title-bar [x] to close them. GUI
disappeared, sounds did not.
I also get this problem. I definitely clicked the [x]. It would be nice to
have a standard File-Close menu entry as well, perhaps accessible via a
right-click on the canvas, so it doesn't destroy the look of the thing. This
menu could usefully contain a MIDI Panic! option. I'm having problems with
MIDI which may not be Bristol's fault.
--
cheers,

tim hall
http://glastonburymusic.org.uk/tim
We are the people We've been waiting for.
Nick Copeland
2006-09-25 13:21:33 UTC
Permalink
There is no 'install' capability. I could put one in, its just that I don't
like attempting to tweak other peoples computers so had the startBristol
script look for its libraries, binaries and bitmaps in its own
subdirectories. The main issue is with the bitmaps and memories, they don't
really have a 'correct' location.

Yes, the patch transparencies are a bit of a performance hog, that is really
noticable with the memories as to maintain this layer each patch has to be
independently removed. This is not really necessary for memories, I still
intend to implement a 'clear all' option that is actually implemented in the
engine (it was needed to ensure that bristol and brighton were in agreement
on the patches.
Optimising all the color management and bitmap rendering code is on my
wishlist which will improve that also. At the moment it has absolutely no
optimisation and yes, that is now noticable. Since the transparency layer is
also going to be used for other features I will work on some changes.
Subject: Re: [linux-audio-user] Re: ANN: bristol 0.9.5-60
Date: Mon, 25 Sep 2006 14:15:04 +0200
Hi,
got bristol compiled and running with jack on ubuntu laptop. Had some fun
with the new ARP 2600 although the gui is a but sluggish while changing
patches from the memorys.
I wounder if there supposed to be an installation routine like
./build install
or something. Couldn't find one and ended up copying the required libs to
the right places manually.
Cheers,
Malte
--
Malte Steiner
media art + development
-www.block4.com-
Norway 12.-15. october
http://java.block4.com/blog4/
_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today it's FREE!
http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/
Malte Steiner
2006-09-25 13:39:24 UTC
Permalink
Hi,
no optimisation and yes, that is now noticable. Since the transparency
layer is also going to be used for other features I will work on some
changes.
just a suggestion:
i didn't looked into the sources so what do you use for GUI painting?
How about using OpenGL? It should run hardware accellerated on recent
machines and comes with transparency, image rotation (read: knobs!),
colorization and sizing included.

Cheers,

Malte
--
Malte Steiner
media art + development
-www.block4.com-

next events:
elektronengehirn exhibition, lecture + concert @ Piksel 2006, Bergen,
Norway 12.-15. october

more at blog 4, also available as rss feed:
http://java.block4.com/blog4/
Lee Revell
2006-09-25 14:04:26 UTC
Permalink
Post by Malte Steiner
Hi,
no optimisation and yes, that is now noticable. Since the transparency
layer is also going to be used for other features I will work on some
changes.
i didn't looked into the sources so what do you use for GUI painting?
How about using OpenGL? It should run hardware accellerated on recent
machines and comes with transparency, image rotation (read: knobs!),
colorization and sizing included.
3D hardware acceleration requires a proprietary driver on most machines.
Please don't make it a requirement.

Lee
Yves Potin
2006-09-25 14:53:21 UTC
Permalink
Post by Lee Revell
3D hardware acceleration requires a proprietary driver on most machines.
Please don't make it a requirement.
I completely agree with that. Even if I run a free driver which
permits me 3D hardware acceleration, I *voluntarily* doesn't use it
because using the module makes my Radeon occupy the same IRQ than my
RME. I would be *very* disappointed to see an audio software make use of
3D ressources.

Y.
tim hall
2006-09-28 10:20:01 UTC
Permalink
Post by Lee Revell
Post by Malte Steiner
Hi,
no optimisation and yes, that is now noticable. Since the transparency
layer is also going to be used for other features I will work on some
changes.
i didn't looked into the sources so what do you use for GUI painting?
How about using OpenGL? It should run hardware accellerated on recent
machines and comes with transparency, image rotation (read: knobs!),
colorization and sizing included.
3D hardware acceleration requires a proprietary driver on most machines.
Please don't make it a requirement.
Two's up on that. My video card is one of the few that doesn't require
proprietary drivers, however its DRI has been broken in Debian testing for
the last few months and the fix has been a long time coming. It would have
been very annoying to not to have been able to join in the fun. Fortunately,
I am getting an idea of what Bristol can do, albeit with a few problems,
which I'll go into when I've had time to investigate properly. Now I'm really
looking forward to the possible development of a virtual Synthi size A.

:)
--
cheers,

tim hall
http://glastonburymusic.org.uk/tim
We are the people We've been waiting for.
Nick Copeland
2006-09-25 15:05:40 UTC
Permalink
I have considered OpenGL, but bristol currently only has dependencies on an
audio library in the engine and Xlib for the GUI. I have previously written
and maintained applications that had other dependencies and they are painful
to manage - not just for development, but also for installation.

There are so many audio tools out there, and many have their own different
set of requirements, its actually quite a ludicrous situation. That is not
too slight any of the applications, they are written for free, writing them
has to be enjoyable for that reason, so it is reasonable that they use
whatever toolkit feels right. For bristol, this toolkit was brighton, it was
a lot of fun to build.

I am also not convinced that 3D is where I want to go - I like the idea, but
it keeps reminding me of starski and hutch style 'go faster stripes'. What I
want to say is that the interface needs to be interesting and 3D would be,
but this is still an audio application and 3D does not improve usability -
probably one of the biggest requirements of bristol at the moment.

Regards,

Nick.
Reply-To: A list for linux audio users
Subject: Re: [linux-audio-user] Re: ANN: bristol 0.9.5-60
Date: Mon, 25 Sep 2006 10:04:26 -0400
Post by Malte Steiner
Hi,
no optimisation and yes, that is now noticable. Since the transparency
layer is also going to be used for other features I will work on some
changes.
i didn't looked into the sources so what do you use for GUI painting?
How about using OpenGL? It should run hardware accellerated on recent
machines and comes with transparency, image rotation (read: knobs!),
colorization and sizing included.
3D hardware acceleration requires a proprietary driver on most machines.
Please don't make it a requirement.
Lee
_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today it's FREE!
http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/
Malte Steiner
2006-09-25 16:03:22 UTC
Permalink
opengl != 3d only

you can use it for 2d stuff too and have the mentioned benefits. I see
the problems which are mentioned here but I dont think gui should be
done in the cpu while even onboard graphic chips have incredible
potential. Of course its problematic with almost every manufacturer and
their closed source drivers (the intels are not really open too, or?),
its such a waste. I hope the open source graphic card project will have
success.

I wonder if the SDL lib has some benefits regarding compositing user
interfaces on Linux...

Cheers,

Malte
--
Malte Steiner
media art + development
-www.block4.com-

next events:
elektronengehirn exhibition, lecture + concert @ Piksel 2006, Bergen,
Norway 12.-15. october

more at blog 4, also available as rss feed:
http://java.block4.com/blog4/
Nick Copeland
2006-09-26 10:03:35 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jean-Baptiste Mestelan
would it be possible for Bristol MIDI connections to show up in
QJackctl or Patchage ? This would enable ignorants like me to patch
Bristol to their MIDI devices :-)
I will be configuring a USB MIDI keyboard presently - I have not had much
time to do it, but it appears in ALSA as device 72:0, bristol appears as
128:0, and aconnect should be able to patch them together. Bristol only
supports raw MIDI or ALSA SEQ, so any other interface is likely to be a
problem at the moment.

Nick.

_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today it's FREE!
http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/
David Baron
2006-09-26 14:57:07 UTC
Permalink
On Tuesday 26 September 2006 11:05,
Post by Jean-Baptiste Mestelan
Post by David Baron
MIDI works fine but one must specify the -mididev if this is not the
first alsa/oss device. Mine being the second one, I have to give it
/dev/midi1 in a OSS mode and hw129:0 in ALSA. I assume there is a way of
(setting up for) using device names instead of this stuff.
how did you make out the correct id (hw129) for your midi device ?
I also have a USB keyboard as my second soundcard, but I cannot make
out its id ...
It is listed in /proc/devices as KONTROL49, but that is not a correct
id for Bristol, obviously ...
Works just fine either way.
Post by Jean-Baptiste Mestelan
would it be possible for Bristol MIDI connections to show up in
QJackctl or Patchage ? This would enable ignorants like me to patch
Bristol to their MIDI devices :-)
Jack stuff should show up in Qjackctl connections and then the user could
connect to whatever input and output he/she chooses (just like most other
jack apps).

It might be nice to have a little control window in Bristol to be able to
dynamically connect rather than have to always do it on the command line but
this is not necessary, especially if jack works and the connections show up!
Dragan Noveski
2006-09-29 13:09:06 UTC
Permalink
Post by Nick Copeland
Bristol has been updated with a user configurable ARP 2600 synth. It
has the usual pre-patching as the original and, additionally, outputs
can be redirected to arbitrary inputs. This was a few changes to
bristol to adjust the engine buffer management for data that may feed
back on itself, and additionally a few extra operators for
electroswitches, reverb and ring-mod, etc. The envelope follower has
not been tested at all and not all the patch possibilities either as
there are honestly too many to go through - about 600 possibilities
with just a single cable.
The biggest changes were in the GUI. To support the user patches an
extra layer was added for their representation, then this was
converted into a transparency layer so the cables can be layered over
the GUI to allow control of the parameters without them 'getting in
the way', then the cables were coloured perhaps somewhat randomly -
yellow patches carry signal left to right, red cables carry signal
right to left when see from the user interface.
Once that was done I put in a cheesy watermarked logo - you can clear
it with the 'l' key or use the '-logo' option on the command line, but
the effect was too good to miss out on. The transparency can be
toggled with the 't' key to allow you to foreground and background the
layer, and 'o'/'O' will adjust the depth of opacity. Load memory
number 17, and play with the 'o' and 't' keys to get a feel for how
the interface works. To patch, select an output (the jack sockets
light up for outputs) and then select an input (these are just
'momentary'). This will direct the new engine routing algorithm for
each voice and then paint in the GUI. To clear a patch just select
either jack socket at the cable ends.
The net output of the synth is reminiscent of the sounds from the BBC
Radiophonic Workshop's greatest ever hit - the theme tune to 'Dr Who'.
If you don't know what that is don't worry, it's perhaps a bit
obscure. The original was composed on the elder brother of this synth
- the ARP 2500 of which the BBC had a few, so the results came as a
pleasant surprise.
Graphics can be seen on the sourceforge homepage. Downloads as well of
course.
https://sourceforge.net/project/screenshots.php?group_id=157415
Regards,
Nick.
_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today it's
FREE! http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/
hi, very nice application, since bristol is now jack-capable.
in my case rhodes, and rhodes-bass arent working, segfault?
but the question that i have is, what i should copy in to usr/local/bin
or /usr/local/lib, so that i can put some menu-entries, so being able to
start from menu?

cheers,
doc
Nick Copeland
2006-09-29 13:22:40 UTC
Permalink
Post by Dragan Noveski
rhodes, and rhodes-bass arent working, segfault?
Not the first complaint about these algorithms failing. To test it you
minimally need read access to the whole tree where you installed and built
bristol so that you can read the memories, then use the startBristol script
in the bin directory: 'startBristol -rhodes'. That is supposed to work, and
if that is how you get segmentation faults then I could do with the output
from a gdb stack backtrace ('gdb <bristol> <core>' then type in "backtrace",
or a core file sent directly to me).
Post by Dragan Noveski
copy in to /usr/local/bin or /usr/local/lib, so that i can put some
menu-entries, so being able to start from menu?
Hm, this is the second request for an install operation. Can you not build
in the full path to the startBristol script, with options, as a menu
command? Is the issue here that libraries cannot be found due to root
permissions and security or that binaries cannot be found if the path is not
configured correctly?

Kind regards,

nick.

_________________________________________________________________
Don't just search. Find. Check out the new MSN Search!
http://search.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200636ave/direct/01/
Dragan Noveski
2006-09-29 13:52:46 UTC
Permalink
Post by Nick Copeland
Post by Dragan Noveski
rhodes, and rhodes-bass arent working, segfault?
Not the first complaint about these algorithms failing. To test it you
minimally need read access to the whole tree where you installed and
built bristol so that you can read the memories, then use the
startBristol script in the bin directory: 'startBristol -rhodes'. That
is supposed to work, and if that is how you get segmentation faults
then I could do with the output from a gdb stack backtrace ('gdb
<bristol> <core>' then type in "backtrace", or a core file sent
directly to me).
i looked now following your instructions, it is not a segfault, but
zombifying jack.
i did:
cd /software/nove/bristol/bristol-0.9.5/bin$

and then:
./startBristol -rhodes -jack

the roads piano appears, it is connected to jack, but trying to play the
keys, no sound, than short time after rhodes stops:

***@murija2:~/software/nove/bristol/bristol-0.9.5/bin$
./startBristol -rhodes -jack
spawning midi thread
parent going into idle loop
connected to :0.0 (81492f0)
display is 1024 by 768 pixels
Window is w 1024, h 768, d 24, 0 0 0
Using DirectColor display
masks are ff0000 ff0000 ff0000
Initialise the rhodes link to bristol: 814dd50
midi sequencer
Opened listening control socket: 5028
Client ID = 129
Queue ID = 0
Device name did not parse, defaults 128.0
hostname is localhost, bristol
port is 5028
Connected to the bristol control socket: 5
bristolengine already active
Accepted connection from 0 (3) onto 2 (5)
created 16 voices: allocated 16 to synth
engine MIDI channel 0
spawning audio thread
registering jack interface
Rescheduled thread: 95
initialising one DX sound
done create interface: 81490c0, 814dd50
brightonWorldChanged(750 250 10 10)
going operational
Found port alsa_pcm:playback_1
Found port alsa_pcm:playback_2
Default connection bristol:out_left to alsa_pcm:playback_1
Default connection bristol:out_right to alsa_pcm:playback_2
Found port alsa_pcm:capture_1
Found port alsa_pcm:capture_2
Default connection alsa_pcm:capture_1 to bristol:in
zombified - calling shutdown handler
unregistering jack interface
cleanupBrighton(0)
midi write error, fd 5, size 1
midi write error, fd 5, size 12
midi write error, fd 5, size 1
return - no data in buffer
socket closed
request acked: -1
***@murija2:~/software/nove/bristol/bristol-0.9.5/bin$

------------

please give me a more precisely "howto" for using "gdb"
Post by Nick Copeland
Post by Dragan Noveski
copy in to /usr/local/bin or /usr/local/lib, so that i can put some
menu-entries, so being able to start from menu?
Hm, this is the second request for an install operation. Can you not
build in the full path to the startBristol script, with options, as a
menu command? Is the issue here that libraries cannot be found due to
root permissions and security or that binaries cannot be found if the
path is not configured correctly?
this part i really dont understand, but i think it is a less problem,
since i can copy the hole build dir somewhere, and than make the
different menu-entries.

cheers,
doc
Post by Nick Copeland
Kind regards,
nick.
_________________________________________________________________
Don't just search. Find. Check out the new MSN Search!
http://search.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200636ave/direct/01/
Paul Winkler
2006-09-29 13:48:11 UTC
Permalink
Post by Nick Copeland
The net output of the synth is reminiscent of the sounds from the BBC
Radiophonic Workshop's greatest ever hit - the theme tune to 'Dr Who'. If
you don't know what that is don't worry, it's perhaps a bit obscure. The
original was composed on the elder brother of this synth - the ARP 2500 of
which the BBC had a few, so the results came as a pleasant surprise.
Can it process external inputs? Or patch e.g. the hammond output into
the ARP input?

If so, feed an organ sound into an ARP patch for some Won't Get Fooled
Again fun :)
--
Paul Winkler
http://www.slinkp.com
Nick Copeland
2006-09-29 14:01:52 UTC
Permalink
Can [the ARP 2600] process external inputs?
It is coded to do so, however this is one part that has not been tested, at
all, so your millage will not exactly vary as it will probably be more like
petrol into a diesel tank. I also think you will get different results from
jack vs alsa drivers as they are organised differently within bristol.
feed an organ sound into an ARP patch for some Won't Get Fooled Again fun
:)
That is currently not possible but is on the list of enhancements.
Eventually bristol may register each synth as separate IO into jack, so you
can then tie it all together as you like. The dirty workaround of invoking
two bristol into jack will also fail as the name space 'bristol' may clash?
I was considering putting the pid into the registration to avoid this issue,
but that remains mildly ugly.

Regards,

Nick.

_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today it's FREE!
http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/
Paul Coccoli
2006-10-02 12:21:42 UTC
Permalink
Post by Nick Copeland
Can [the ARP 2600] process external inputs?
It is coded to do so, however this is one part that has not been tested, at
all, so your millage will not exactly vary as it will probably be more like
petrol into a diesel tank. I also think you will get different results from
jack vs alsa drivers as they are organised differently within bristol.
feed an organ sound into an ARP patch for some Won't Get Fooled Again fun
:)
That is currently not possible but is on the list of enhancements.
Eventually bristol may register each synth as separate IO into jack, so you
can then tie it all together as you like. The dirty workaround of invoking
two bristol into jack will also fail as the name space 'bristol' may clash?
I was considering putting the pid into the registration to avoid this issue,
but that remains mildly ugly.
Regards,
Nick.
Why not put the synth name in the IO port name? Unless you already
do, in which case I'm not sure what you mean by a namespace clash.
Nick Copeland
2006-09-29 14:09:31 UTC
Permalink
The 'zombied' message from jack and the 'midi write error' from brighton
indicate that bristol, the engine, has ungracefully exit, most typically a
segfault. Depending on your shell and write permissions on the 'bin'
directory you may be able to do the following:

***@murija2:~/software/nove/bristol/bristol-0.9.5/bin$ limit
coredumpsize unlimited
***@murija2:~/software/nove/bristol/bristol-0.9.5/bin$ ./startBristol
-rhodes -jack

Now do whatever until the error occurs and if you now close the synth window
from the title bar you will get a core dump IF you have write permissions in
the current directory. If you do not want to have write permissions on the
bristol/bin directory then try the following:

***@murija2:~/software/nove/bristol/bristol-0.9.5/bin$ cd /tmp
***@murija2:/tmp$ ~/software/nove/bristol/bristol-0.9.5/startBristol
-rhodes -jack

The coredump as an enclosure, or the stack backtrace from GDB will help to
track down the cause of the problem.

Regards,

Nick.
Reply-To: A list for linux audio users
Subject: Re: [linux-audio-user] ANN: bristol 0.9.5-60
Date: Fri, 29 Sep 2006 15:52:46 +0200
Post by Nick Copeland
Post by Dragan Noveski
rhodes, and rhodes-bass arent working, segfault?
Not the first complaint about these algorithms failing. To test it you
minimally need read access to the whole tree where you installed and built
bristol so that you can read the memories, then use the startBristol
script in the bin directory: 'startBristol -rhodes'. That is supposed to
work, and if that is how you get segmentation faults then I could do with
the output from a gdb stack backtrace ('gdb <bristol> <core>' then type in
"backtrace", or a core file sent directly to me).
i looked now following your instructions, it is not a segfault, but
zombifying jack.
cd /software/nove/bristol/bristol-0.9.5/bin$
./startBristol -rhodes -jack
the roads piano appears, it is connected to jack, but trying to play the
-rhodes -jack
spawning midi thread
parent going into idle loop
connected to :0.0 (81492f0)
display is 1024 by 768 pixels
Window is w 1024, h 768, d 24, 0 0 0
Using DirectColor display
masks are ff0000 ff0000 ff0000
Initialise the rhodes link to bristol: 814dd50
midi sequencer
Opened listening control socket: 5028
Client ID = 129
Queue ID = 0
Device name did not parse, defaults 128.0
hostname is localhost, bristol
port is 5028
Connected to the bristol control socket: 5
bristolengine already active
Accepted connection from 0 (3) onto 2 (5)
created 16 voices: allocated 16 to synth
engine MIDI channel 0
spawning audio thread
registering jack interface
Rescheduled thread: 95
initialising one DX sound
done create interface: 81490c0, 814dd50
brightonWorldChanged(750 250 10 10)
going operational
Found port alsa_pcm:playback_1
Found port alsa_pcm:playback_2
Default connection bristol:out_left to alsa_pcm:playback_1
Default connection bristol:out_right to alsa_pcm:playback_2
Found port alsa_pcm:capture_1
Found port alsa_pcm:capture_2
Default connection alsa_pcm:capture_1 to bristol:in
zombified - calling shutdown handler
unregistering jack interface
cleanupBrighton(0)
midi write error, fd 5, size 1
midi write error, fd 5, size 12
midi write error, fd 5, size 1
return - no data in buffer
socket closed
request acked: -1
------------
please give me a more precisely "howto" for using "gdb"
Post by Nick Copeland
Post by Dragan Noveski
copy in to /usr/local/bin or /usr/local/lib, so that i can put some
menu-entries, so being able to start from menu?
Hm, this is the second request for an install operation. Can you not build
in the full path to the startBristol script, with options, as a menu
command? Is the issue here that libraries cannot be found due to root
permissions and security or that binaries cannot be found if the path is
not configured correctly?
this part i really dont understand, but i think it is a less problem, since
i can copy the hole build dir somewhere, and than make the different
menu-entries.
cheers,
doc
Post by Nick Copeland
Kind regards,
nick.
_________________________________________________________________
Don't just search. Find. Check out the new MSN Search!
http://search.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200636ave/direct/01/
_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today it's FREE!
http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/
Dragan Noveski
2006-09-29 14:35:23 UTC
Permalink
Post by Nick Copeland
The 'zombied' message from jack and the 'midi write error' from
brighton indicate that bristol, the engine, has ungracefully exit,
most typically a segfault. Depending on your shell and write
coredumpsize unlimited
as root, or as a user:

bash: limit: command not found
Post by Nick Copeland
./startBristol -rhodes -jack
Now do whatever until the error occurs and if you now close the synth
window from the title bar you will get a core dump IF you have write
permissions in the current directory. If you do not want to have write
~/software/nove/bristol/bristol-0.9.5/startBristol -rhodes -jack
not sure if this is right:

***@murija2:/tmp$
/home/nowhiskey/software/nove/bristol/bristol-0.9.5/bin/startBristol
-rhodes -jack
spawning midi thread
parent going into idle loop
midi sequencer
Opened listening control socket: 5028
connected to :0.0 (81492f0)
display is 1024 by 768 pixels
Window is w 1024, h 768, d 24, 0 0 0
Using DirectColor display
masks are ff0000 ff0000 ff0000
Initialise the rhodes link to bristol: 814dd50
Client ID = 129
Queue ID = 0
Device name did not parse, defaults 128.0
hostname is localhost, bristol
port is 5028
Connected to the bristol control socket: 5
bristolengine already active
Accepted connection from 0 (3) onto 2 (5)
created 16 voices: allocated 16 to synth
engine MIDI channel 0
spawning audio thread
registering jack interface
Rescheduled thread: 95
initialising one DX sound
done create interface: 81490c0, 814dd50
brightonWorldChanged(750 250 10 10)
going operational
Found port alsa_pcm:playback_1
Found port alsa_pcm:playback_2
Default connection bristol:out_left to alsa_pcm:playback_1
Default connection bristol:out_right to alsa_pcm:playback_2
Found port alsa_pcm:capture_1
Found port alsa_pcm:capture_2
Default connection alsa_pcm:capture_1 to bristol:in
zombified - calling shutdown handler
unregistering jack interface
midi write error, fd 5, size 1
cleanupBrighton(0)
midi write error, fd 5, size 1
midi write error, fd 5, size 12
midi write error, fd 5, size 1
return - no data in buffer
socket closed
request acked: -1
***@murija2:/tmp$


cheers,
doc
Post by Nick Copeland
The coredump as an enclosure, or the stack backtrace from GDB will
help to track down the cause of the problem.
Regards,
Nick.
Nick Copeland
2006-10-01 10:41:18 UTC
Permalink
to programmatically _check_ the sample rate that ACK is set to
I will look into this as well as it should be possible and would clean up
the interface considerably.
I needed to manually add a MIDI input connector to JACK for Bristol, and
"connect"
I recently bought a USB keyboard, it works here with aconnect but that is
because I do not always run jack. I am pleased to know that qjackctl works
though.
No response to pitch-bend or mod-wheels, it seems.
Funnily enough I uploaded -66 yesterday night. If fixes a number of issues I
found from linking up the USB keyboard. Pitch bend was broken, it should now
be fixed. The Mod wheel should work, in as much as I link it to CC #1, but
some of the synth patches will not respond to Mod - depth and effect are
sometimes controlled by the synth settings. If the Mod does anything then it
should be audible from the GUI mod wheel. If that does anything but the
synth mod wheel does not then it is a bug. At the moment bristol will not
remap CC to controls, which means the fix is probably something I have to
do.

I am working on code to allow you to link arbitrary CC into bristol
controls, and to give more GM-2 support, but that is a little way off.

The other things that was broken is keyboard assigment and release - note
on/off can intermittently be lost. I was surprised by this, not just that it
happens but also that it was so pronounced. It turned out to be an issue
that I never saw with a standard MIDI interface, I could read note messages
and apply them faster than MIDI could deliver them at 31.25KHz. The USB
interface is considerably faster, so my code, which only executed one note
message per 'select()' could fail. This is an odd interface to the ALSA SEQ
but was easy enough to fix once the penny dropped.

Work is going on to change a lot of the MIDI code. Sustain does not work in
-66 (although that was fixed last night), programme change is not
implemented but is high on the list and loads of other stuff.

Regards,

Nick.

_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today it's FREE!
http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/
Sylvain Robitaille
2006-10-02 19:56:27 UTC
Permalink
Funnily enough I uploaded -66 yesterday night. ...
Will try that (hopefully this evening). It sounds like at least the most
important (to me) items I've brought up are addressed in that version.
Thank you.
The other things that was broken is keyboard assigment and release -
note on/off can intermittently be lost.
I wonder if this is what caused a symptom I've occasionally noticed,
particularly with some of the emulations where it seemed at times that
the envelopes weren't always retriggering. I wasn't yet sure whether
this was due to anything of my own fault (anything from the retriggering
getting lost within my setup to perhaps simply poor playing technique).
If this symptom is no longer noticeable with -66, then that must be it.
Otherwise, I'll try and narrow it down before "officially" reporting it.
Work is going on to change a lot of the MIDI code. Sustain does not
work in -66 (although that was fixed last night), programme change is
not implemented but is high on the list and loads of other stuff.
I can be patient. :-) Thanks again!
--
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Sylvain Robitaille ***@alcor.concordia.ca

Major in Electroacoustic Studies Concordia University
Faculty of Fine Arts / Music Department Montreal, Quebec, Canada
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Sylvain Robitaille
2006-10-03 03:22:12 UTC
Permalink
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
Funnily enough I uploaded -66 yesterday night. ...
Well, that definitely fixes the pitch-bend controller response, and
to some extent the mod-wheel response as well. With that one, I find
(at least with most of the default patches) that either the mod-wheel
reacts too much, or it isn't affecting the sound in a way that I expect.
This may be just something relevant to the patches themselves, though.
I haven't investigated this enough to be able to provide a better report,
I'm afraid.
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
Will try that (hopefully this evening).
Done. I even tried it with the guitar-to-MIDI converter: that's a
non-starter, though. The tracking with Bristol is extremely uneven, and
in fact with the guitar-controller Bristol does not play in tune at all
(either with the guitar itself, or with other keyboards which are indeed
tuned to each other), while it's mostly fine with the keyboard controllers
(and the keyboard synths track fine with the guitar controller).

Interestingly, though, it seems to me that the B3 plays a semitone (or so)
sharp (compared to my piano). I checked that at both 48KHz and 44.1KHz.
No way to tune the B3? I see (heard!) what you mean about being careful
with the gain option and the B3! :-) I don't understand, though,
why that emulation is so much louder than the others.
Post by Sylvain Robitaille
The other things that was broken is keyboard assigment and release -
note on/off can intermittently be lost.
This indeed may have been what was causing the behaviour I discussed
earlier. -66 doesn't seem to exhibit that behaviour on my system (or at
least I have to play purposely sloppily, or with the guitar-controller
for it to happen).

I tried experimenting with some of the synthesizer emulations (primarily
the Prophet-5 and the PolySix). It's been a very long time since I had
my hands on hardware versions of these, but I'm having trouble wrapping
my head around the emulations on Bristol. I'll probably need to refer
to readme.synths _while_ tweaking sounds, to be sure I'm adjusting what
I _think_ I'm adjusting.

Thank you, by the way, for readme.synths. I've spotted a few typos in
that file, that if I can find the time (and you don't mind) I'd like to
submit corrections for. That file is an interesting read above and
beyond its description of the controls available for each emulation.
:-)
--
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Sylvain Robitaille ***@alcor.concordia.ca

Major in Electroacoustic Studies Concordia University
Faculty of Fine Arts / Music Department Montreal, Quebec, Canada
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Nick Copeland
2006-10-02 13:11:38 UTC
Permalink
Post by Paul Coccoli
Why not put the synth name in the IO port name? Unless you already
do, in which case I'm not sure what you mean by a namespace clash.
There are problems here due to the engine being multitimbral, so a few
examples:

1. Single engine, multiple emulations (multitimbral Hammond and ARP 2600):

If the bristol engine first registers with the synth name then it starts
using Hammond for its IO. Then the signal from ARP 2600, which is started
afterwards, will come from the outputs named Hammond which is rather
ambiguous. This could almost be resolved with registering separate IO for
each emulation, but there there is case 2:

2. Single engine, multiple emulations (Prophet-5 and another Prophet-5):

These might be two different invocations of the same synth, however at the
same time this is pretty much how the Prophet-10 works (and the OBXa, and
the B3 kind of). This causes other issues with available namespace inside
the single registration. Why should a user not be able to have two Mini Moog
operating simultaneously using either methods described above? Neither
solution to case 1 or case 2 address this possibility.

2. Multiple Engines

Each engine would be affected by both of the above issues. Bristol was
designed to be able to produce all emulations simultenously.

The current 'workaround', which has not been uploaded yet, is that bristol
will register as itself. If that fails it will attempt to register
'bristol_<pid>'. This may cause other issues regarding LASH understanding
the use of a PID in connection settings as the PID will invariably change
between invocations? LASH support it not actually there yet, but it is on
the horizon so obviously needs to be considered whilst solving this problem.

All output from each synth us still currently collapsed by bristol onto the
same stereo outputs, this may give issues with mixing, obviously.

I am open to suggestions. Should the user give an optional registration
name? Even that goes against the grain of usability.

Regards,

Nick.

_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today it's FREE!
http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/
Nick Copeland
2006-10-21 17:39:13 UTC
Permalink
Build 89 has been uploaded to sourceforge. It is likely to be unstable since
quite large changes were made to the MIDI interface to support controller
tracking in the GUI. The 2600 should now be finalised including the output
bussing fixes and voltage manipulators. The sustain pedal should now work,
lightly tested. MIDI controllers can be remapped internally, only interface
is the text configuration file in $BRISTOL/memory/profiles/<synth>, you can
edit this at your own risk.

Controller changes allow for MIDI surfaces to control the GUI, and hence the
engine. Rather spuriously, to be able to modify and play the synth then both
the GUI and engine need to be patched into the MIDI devices with whatever
connection application you prefer - controller changes are tracked in the
GUI and this causes the parameter changes to be sent to the engine.

Having this support immensely enhances tweaking the synths. You can map
controllers by clicking the middle mouse button in a device and then moving
the desired controller. You can select multiple devices to enable ganging of
controls and the controller profile should be maintained. The mappings for
each algorithm are saved when a patch is saved. They are only loaded on
boot, but mappings should not be volatile. Reselecting a device with the
same middle mouse button will remove the registration.

Pitch and Pan controllers should now be notched in the GUI, and a fine
adjust is available with <Control><Button_1_Motion>.

The rotary shading was altered and a few other fixes were integrated. The
transparent patch layer was optimised bya factor of 4 to 5 fold so loading
the 2600 memories should be a lot faster.

Feedback on the controller mappings would be greatly appreciated, the
interface is new and will probably give some problems. When the interface
works then program change support will be integrated along with more GM2
functionality.

Regards,

Nick.

_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today it's FREE!
http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/

Loading...